/
Serijske publikacije
/
Razprave in gradivo
Spreminjajoči se pomen vsebine kriterijev opredeljevanja (narodnih) manjšin
Avtor(ji):Petra Roter
Soavtor(ji):Boris Jesih (odg. ur.)
Leto:2008
Založnik(i):Inštitut za narodnostna vprašanja, Ljubljana
Jezik(i):slovenščina
Vrst(e) gradiva:besedilo
Datoteke (1)
Ime:Razprave_in_gradiva-56-57.pdf
Velikost:5.26MB
Format:application/pdf
Stalna povezava:https://hdl.handle.net/11686/file400
Opis
Prispevek analizira razvoj pojmovanja narodnih manjšin in pristope k identifikaciji manjšin, ki so upravičene do posebnega varstva. S pomočjo obširne analize različnih primarnih virov prispevek obravnava razumevanje manjšin od obdobja Društva narodov do vključno sedanjega režima za varstvo narodnih manjšin, in sicer na podlagi analize treh načinov opredeljevanja manjšin iz tega obdobja, ki so v prispevku opredeljeni kot pravni, normativni in implementacijski. Prispevek pokaže, prvič, da se je sčasoma kljub odsotnosti konsenzualne definicije manjšin utrdilo prepričanje, da je za identifikacijo manjšin potreben obstoj objektivno različnih skupnosti ter volja njihovih članov, da ohranjajo svojo posebno identiteto, hkrati pa samo priznanje obstoja manjšine nima konstitutivnega pomena – torej obstoj manjšine ni odvisen od njenega priznanja. In drugič, da se je pojmovanje manjšin na mednarodni ravni razvijalo tako, da razumevanje upravičencev do varstva manjšin v veliki meri presega tradicionalno pojmovanje narodnih manjšin kot zgodovinskih, ozemeljsko strnjenih skupnosti, ki so trdno (z državljanstvom) in dolgotrajno povezane z državo, v kateri njihovi pripadniki živijo. Takšno razumevanje posledično vpliva na varstvo manjšin v praksi.
Metapodatki (11)
- identifikatorhttps://hdl.handle.net/11686/9495
- naslov
- Spreminjajoči se pomen vsebine kriterijev opredeljevanja (narodnih) manjšin
- The Changing Significance of the Criteria for (National) Minority Identification
- avtor
- Petra Roter
- soavtor
- Boris Jesih (odg. ur.)
- predmet
- narodna manjšina
- definicija
- mednarodno varstvo manjšin
- mednarodne institucije
- national minority
- definition
- international minority protection
- international institutions
- opis
- The article analyses the development of minority identification and different approaches towards identification of minorities as objects of minority protection. Based on a comprehensive analysis of numerous primary sources (documents), the article studies the prevailing understandings of minorities in the period from the League of Nations to the contemporary post-Cold War international regime for national minority protection. Three prevailing approaches to minority identification can be traced in this period; they are identified as the legal, the normative and the implementational approach. The article shows, firstly, that although there is no consensual definition of the term minority, there appears to be an agreement that for minority identification, two criteria need to be met: the de facto existence of distinct communities, and the willingness/desire of persons belonging to them to preserve their distinct identity. Also, recognition of minorities in itself has no constitutive significance: a minority’s existence is not dependent on its formal recognition by the relevant authorities. The article shows, secondly, that the criteria (their contents, significance and their meaning) for minority identification in the international community have gradually changed to the extent that the contemporary understanding of the objects of minority protection extends beyond the traditional one referring to historical, territorially based national minorities, whose members maintain firm and long-lasting ties with the state of their residence (i.e. are citizens and live permanently for a long time in that state). In turn, such changing significance of the criteria for minority identification has affected minority protection in practice.
- Prispevek analizira razvoj pojmovanja narodnih manjšin in pristope k identifikaciji manjšin, ki so upravičene do posebnega varstva. S pomočjo obširne analize različnih primarnih virov prispevek obravnava razumevanje manjšin od obdobja Društva narodov do vključno sedanjega režima za varstvo narodnih manjšin, in sicer na podlagi analize treh načinov opredeljevanja manjšin iz tega obdobja, ki so v prispevku opredeljeni kot pravni, normativni in implementacijski. Prispevek pokaže, prvič, da se je sčasoma kljub odsotnosti konsenzualne definicije manjšin utrdilo prepričanje, da je za identifikacijo manjšin potreben obstoj objektivno različnih skupnosti ter volja njihovih članov, da ohranjajo svojo posebno identiteto, hkrati pa samo priznanje obstoja manjšine nima konstitutivnega pomena – torej obstoj manjšine ni odvisen od njenega priznanja. In drugič, da se je pojmovanje manjšin na mednarodni ravni razvijalo tako, da razumevanje upravičencev do varstva manjšin v veliki meri presega tradicionalno pojmovanje narodnih manjšin kot zgodovinskih, ozemeljsko strnjenih skupnosti, ki so trdno (z državljanstvom) in dolgotrajno povezane z državo, v kateri njihovi pripadniki živijo. Takšno razumevanje posledično vpliva na varstvo manjšin v praksi.
- založnik
- Inštitut za narodnostna vprašanja
- datum
- 2008
- tip
- besedilo
- jezik
- Slovenščina
- jeDelOd
Seznam literature v delu (39)
| Stran | Avtor | Naslov | Vir | Kraj | Založba | Leto |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 62 | Barker, Ernest | Principles of social & political theory | Oxford | Clarendon Press | 1951 | |
| 62 | Barrington, Lowell | Rethinking the triadic nexus: external national homelands, international organisations, and ethnic relations in the former Soviet Union : The Fourth Annual Convention of the Association for the Study of Nationalities | New York | 1999 | ||
| 62 | Benoît-Rohmer, Florence | The minority question in Europe: towards a coherent system of protection for national minorities : texts and commentary | Strasbourg | Council of Europe | 1996 | |
| 62 | Bilder, Richard B. | Can minorities treaties work? | The protection of minorities and human rights | Dordrecht, Boston, London | Martinus Nijhoff Publishers | 1992 |
| 62 | Brennan, Katherine ; Brody Reed, et al | The 40th session of the UN Sub-Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities | Human Rights Quarterly | 1989 | ||
| 63 | Brubaker W., Rogers | Citizenship struggles in Soviet successor states | International Migration Review | 1992 | ||
| 63 | Brunner, Georg | Nationality problems and minority conflicts in Eastern Europe: strategies for Europe | Gütersloh | Bertelsmann Foundation Publishers | 1996 | |
| 63 | Capotorti, Francesco | Minorities | Encyclopedia of public international law, Instalment 8 | Amsterdam, new York, Oxford | Elsevier Science Publishers | 1985 |
| 63 | Chaliand, Gérard | Minority peoples in the age of nation-states | Minority peoples in the age of nation-states | London | Pluto Press | 1989 |
| 63 | Chaszar, Edward | The international problem of national minorities | Indiana | Indiana University in Pennsylvania | 1988 | |
| 63 | Chaszar, Edward | The international problem of national minorities | Toronto, Buffalo | Matthias Corvinus Publishing | 1999 | |
| 63 | Claude, Inis L. | National minorities: an international problem | Cambridge | Harvard University Press | 1955 | |
| 64 | Gál, Kinga | The role of bilateral treaties in the protection of national minorities in Central and Eastern Europe | Helsinki Monitor | 1999 | ||
| 64 | Galántai, József | Trianon and the protection of minorities | Highland Lakes, New Jersey, Boulder | Social Sciences Monographs, Atlantic Research and Publications | 1992 | |
| 65 | Grigorievs, Alex | The Baltic predicament | Europe’s new nationalism. States and minorities in conflict | New York, Oxford | Oxford University Press | 1996 |
| 65 | Helgesen, Jan | Protecting minorities in the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe (CSCE) process | The strength of diversity: human rights and pluralist democracy | Dordrecht, Boston, London | Martinus Nijhoff Publishers | 1992 |
| 65 | Helton, Arthur C. | International legal principles concerning national minorities : Seminar on New Diasporas of Eastern Europe | http://www.osi.hu/fmp/html/minority.html | Budapest | Open Society Institute, Forced Migration Projects | 1998 |
| 65 | Hrissimova, Ognyana | The League of Nations and the problem of minorities in the Balkans after the end of the First World War | The League of Nations 1920–1946: organization and accomplishments. A retrospective of the first international organization for the establishment of world peace | New York, Geneva | United Nations | 1996 |
| 65 | Jackson Preece, Jennifer | Minority rights: between diversity and community | Oxford | Polity | 2005 | |
| 65 | Kly Yussuf, Naim | Societal development & minority rights | Atlanta | Clarity Press | 1997 | |
| 65 | Kunz, Josef L. | The present status of international law for the protection of minorities | American Journal of International Law | 1954 | ||
| 65 | Lerner, Natan | The 1992 UN Declaration on minorities | Israel Yearbook on Human Rights | 1993 | ||
| 65 | Macartney ; Carlilie A. | National states and national minorities | London | Oxford University Press, Humphrey Milford | 1934 | |
| 65 | Malloy, Tove H. | National Minority Rights in Europe | Oxford | Oxford University Press | 2005 | |
| 66 | Miall, Hugh | Introduction | Minority rights in Europe: the scope for a transnational regime | London | Pinter Publishers | 1994 |
| 66 | Pearson, Raymond | National minorities in Eastern Europe 1848–1945 | London, Basingstoke | Macmillan Press | 1983 | |
| 66 | Pejic, Jelena | Minority rights in international law | Human Rights Quarterly | 1997 | ||
| 66 | Pentassuglia, Gaetano | Defining “minority” in international law: a critical appraisal | Rovaniemi | Lapland's University Press | 2000 | |
| 66 | Pentassuglia, Gaetano | Minorities in international law | Strasbourg | Council of Europe Publishing | 2002 | |
| 66 | Pogany, Istvan | Minority rights in Central and Eastern Europe: old dilemmas, new solutions? | Minority and group rights in the new millennium | The Hague, Boston, London | Martinus Nijhoff Publishers | 1999 |
| 67 | Roter, Petra | Locating the ‘minority problem’ in Europe: a historical perspective | Journal of International Relations and Development | 2001 | ||
| 67 | Roter, Petra | Managing the ‘minority problem’ in post-Cold War Europe within the framework of a multilayered regime for the protection of national minorities | European yearbook of minority issues | The Hague | Kluwer Law International | 2003 |
| 67 | Roter, Petra | Pojmovanje in opredeljevanje manjšin | Priseljenci: študije o priseljevanju in vključevanju v slovensko družbo | Ljubljana | INV | 2007 |
| 67 | Shaw, Malcolm N. | The definition of minorities in international law | The protection of minorities and human rights | Dordrecht, Boston, London | Martinus Nijhoff Publishers | 1992 |
| 67 | Spiliopoulou Åkermark, Athanasia | Justification of minority protection in international law | London, The Hague, Boston | Kluwer Law International | 2007 | |
| 67 | van der Stoel, Max | Case Studies on National Minority Issues: Positive Results : Keynote address of Mr Max van der Stoel CSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities at the CSCE Human Dimension Seminar | Warsaw | 1993 | ||
| 67 | van der Stoel, Max | The OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities: High Commissioner Max van der Stoel | OSCE ODIHR Bulletin | 1995 | ||
| 67 | van der Stoel, Max | Minority protection, integration and stability in South-Eastern Europe : Speech by the OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities at the Conference on “Democracy, Human Rights and the Protection of Persons Belonging to Minorities in South-Eastern Europe | Bled, Slovenia | 2001 | ||
| 68 | Zaagman, Rob | Conflict prevention in the Baltic states: the OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania | Flensburg | European Centre for Minority Issues | 1999 |